After nearly six weeks of trial in Missouri state court, Paul Boehm, Michelle Ramirez, and Morgan Branch of Sidley Austin secured a defense verdict for Monsanto in a three-plaintiff Roundup trial—the first after the U.S. Supreme Court’s June decision in Monsanto Co. v. Durnell.
Nov 06, 2026 View in Browser

Law.com

Litigation Daily

Analyzing the Intersection of Litigation and the Business of Law

Good morning. It’s Friday, Nov. 6, and I’m Litigation Daily editor and columnist Ross Todd here with the latest Litigator of the Week Runners-Up and Shout-Outs. Keep the nominations coming my way at ross.todd@law.com..

 

First up this week are Laura King and Faith Gay of Selendy Gay and their co-counsel Carla Weiss of Nichols Law, who scored a pair of significant wins for autonomous boat maker Saildrone in its challenge to the Navy's handling of the $2.1 billion Medium Unmanned Surface Vessel competition. The team defeated the government's bid to dismiss the case, persuading U.S. Judge Philip Hadji of the Court of Federal Claims that the court had jurisdiction to review the dispute even though the competition was structured as an "Other Transaction" agreement. The government argued that the contracting vehicle, increasingly used by the Pentagon to develop and acquire emerging technologies, fell outside the court's bid-protest jurisdiction.

 

The team then prevailed on the merits, convincing the court that the Navy acted arbitrarily by excluding Saildrone from the competition while advancing another bidder that had made similar errors in its proposal materials. Judge Hadji set aside the agency's decision, ordered a reevaluation, and barred the Navy from obligating more than $1.5 billion of the program's funding pending that review.

 

A trial team led by Jennifer Saulino of Sidley Austin; Edward Fanning of McCarter & English; and Kate Helm and Brandee Kowalzyk of Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough secured a complete defense verdict for Becton Dickinson and Co. and its Bard subsidiary in the third bellwether trial over the PowerPort medical device. The Arizona federal jury rejected the plaintiff's strict-liability and negligent design-defect claims, as well as her fraudulent-concealment claim, and found that the PowerPort was not defective. The plaintiff, a Florida resident, alleged she developed a severe infection and sepsis after receiving the device in 2013. The team representing BD and Bard included Sidley's Jaime Simon, Elizabeth Ertle, Tyler VanderMolen, Gilbert Smolenski, Kailey Fairchild, Keira Garrett and James Staub.

 

A Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr team led by Christopher Babbitt helped the North Fork Rancheria of Mono Indians fend off a rival tribe's effort to block the opening of its long-planned $700 million casino in Madera County, California. U.S. District Judge Kirk Sherriff denied a preliminary injunction sought by the Picayune Rancheria of the Chukchansi Indians and rejected Picayune's challenge to the National Indian Gaming Commission's approval of North Fork's casino management contract. The judge also ruled that North Fork's sovereign immunity barred Picayune's claim under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and dismissed the case without leave to amend. The ruling cleared the way for North Fork to continue operating the casino, which opened the day before the decision. Babbitt argued for North Fork at the injunction hearing. The Wilmer team included Seth Waxman, Joshua Vittor, Britany Riley Swanbeck, Nitisha Baronia and Mairead Ahlbach.

 

Kannon Shanmugam and a team at Davis Polk & Wardwell helped AbbVie win the first successful challenge to a drug's selection for the Medicare Drug Price Negotiation Program established under the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act. Last week, U.S. District Judge Carl J. Nichols granted summary judgment to AbbVie, holding that Botox falls within the statute's exclusion for plasma-derived products. Nichols vacated CMS's selection of Botox for the program and enjoined the agency from applying the program to it. Shanmugam argued the summary judgment motion for AbbVie. The Davis Polk team included counsel Jamie Durling and associate Eleanor Ritter.

 

Shout-Out to a Beveridge & Diamond team led by Michael Murphy and Katrina Krebs that secured a unanimous victory at New York’s Appellate Division, Third Department for Seneca Meadows Inc., operator of New York's largest landfill. Last week the court affirmed dismissal of claims brought by environmental groups, local businesses and residents challenging the landfill's operations, holding that efforts to block a pending landfill-expansion permit process were not ripe for review and that New York's Green Amendment did not provide a basis to compel discretionary enforcement action by state regulators. The court also held that the business plaintiffs failed to plead the kind of special injury necessary to pursue a public nuisance claim. The Beveridge team included James Slaughter, Vetone Ivezaj and Tim Nevins.

 

Shout-Out to a Bracewell trial team led by Richard F. Whiteley that defended Ironman Recycling, SWD East Texas and GEP Haynesville II in a Texas Business Court trial over the ownership, operation and financial management of an East Texas saltwater disposal facility. Jurors found that GEP did not breach the parties' master services agreement and awarded no damages to the plaintiffs. They also awarded Ironman $2.51 million on a counterclaim for intentional interference and another $120,000 on a fraud claim involving representations about equipment at the facility, while other claims remain pending for the court to decide. The Bracewell team included Cole A. Thoms, Eston Jones, Joshua Strauss, Pamela Parrott and Christine Richards.

 

Shout-out to the team at Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton that secured emergency relief for client FullBeauty Brands in a Delaware merger dispute. After an Oct. 29 hearing, Vice Chancellor Kyle H. Lachmund temporarily enjoined Destination XL Group Inc. from terminating the parties' merger agreement and ordered the case onto an expedited track. The Cleary team included partners Roger Cooper, Elizabeth Hanft and Alexander Talarides, along with associates Katherine MacAdam, Adrian Gariboldi and Ariel Sheffey.

 

Shout-Out to Kate Bolger, Amanda Levine and Meenakshi Krishnan of Davis Wright Tremaine; Andrew Levander and Steven Engel of Dechert; and George LeMieux and Eric Edison of Gunster. They secured the dismissal with prejudice of President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation suit against The Wall Street Journal, News Corp. and several journalists over the newspaper's reporting about a birthday letter Trump purportedly created for Jeffrey Epstein. U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles in Miami held that Trump again failed to plausibly allege actual malice, finding that the Journal's reporting reflected a "thoughtful and detailed investigation." The judge also rejected the argument that journalists act with actual malice simply by publishing allegations that a public figure denies.

 

Shout-Out to Lincoln Bisbee and Michael Kenneally of Morgan Lewis & Bockius, who secured a defense win for Boeing in a proposed wage-and-hour class and collective action. A South Carolina federal judge held that employees' time spent waiting for and riding company-mandated shuttles from a remote parking lot to Boeing's North Charleston plant was “not compensable” under the Fair Labor Standards Act, rejecting claims that the transportation was integral and indispensable to their work. U.S. District Judge David Norton dismissed the FLSA claim with prejudice and dismissed the accompanying contract without prejudice.

 

Shout-Out to an appellate team at Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe led by Eric Shumsky and Cesar Lopez-Morales that secured a published Ninth Circuit decision for Meta Platforms affirming dismissal of claims arising from Facebook's removal of a publisher's accounts and content. In a precedential opinion involving claims brought by Shared Partnership, a creator of sensationalistic online content, the court held that plaintiffs cannot evade Section 230 by merely reframing publisher-liability claims as breach-of-contract claims. Shumsky argued the appeal for Meta. The appellate team also included Samantha Leff. The trial team that secured dismissal in the district court was led by Jake Heath and included Nathan Shaffer, Catherine Lui, Andrew Silverman, Naomi Scotten and Kristopher Wood.

 

Litigators of the Week: In First Roundup Trial After SCOTUS Decision, A Defense Win for Monsanto

 

Our Litigators of the Week are Paul Boehm, Michelle Ramirez and Morgan Branch of Sidley Austin, who represented Monsanto in the first Roundup trial to reach a jury since the U.S. Supreme Court's June decision in Monsanto v. Durnell reshaped the litigation landscape this spring.

 

The three plaintiffs, all Florida residents, claimed that years of exposure to the company's blockbuster herbicide caused them to develop non-Hodgkin lymphoma. But after nearly six weeks of trial in Missouri state court, a St. Louis County jury handed Monsanto a complete defense verdict, rejecting the plaintiffs' design defect, negligence and personal injury claims in less than two hours of deliberation. The verdict was closely watched as an early test of Roundup cases following the Supreme Court's ruling..

 

Lit Daily: What was at stake for Monsanto in this trial?  

 

Paul Boehm: It’s a significant win for our client and an important moment in the litigation. This was the first Roundup trial since the Supreme Court’s ruling in Durnell, which confirmed that plaintiffs’ failure-to-warn claims are preempted under federal law. So beating back plaintiffs’ design defect, fraud, negligence, and other claims—and winning directed verdict on punitive damages along the way—sends an important message.

 

How did this matter come to you and your team?

 

Michelle Ramirez: Bayer is one of Sidley’s longstanding life sciences clients. In 2025, when Paul was with a different law firm, Bayer paired Paul and me together as trial counsel. We had not worked together before, and it was trial magic. So when Bayer asked us to partner together again—and now we are at the same firm—for the first post-Durnell trial, we were thrilled.

 

Who was on your team, and how did you divide responsibilities at trial?

 

Ramirez: We were so fortunate to partner with some of the best lawyers in the country. Erik Hansell from Husch Blackwell was our extraordinary Missouri-based trial counsel, and Justin Benson from Bryan Cave led the law and briefing team. The Sidley team included Rachel McKenzie, Amanda Blau, Tommy Hoyt, Robert Santamarina, Jennifer Kuo, Sarah King and Dana Velcovich. And none of this would be possible without the amazing team from Nelson Mullins, who provided critical support on the science, as well as from legal assistants and tech and graphics support.

 

This was the third case Paul and I have tried together, and we have a good sense of how to best divide trial work. The bottom line, though, is it was extraordinarily collaborative. We worked closely together on both opening and closing, as well as witness outlines and jury selection, to ensure consistency on themes and key points. And the jury definitely noticed and appreciated that we worked together as a team.

 

As Paul noted, this was the first Roundup trial after the Supreme Court's ruling in Monsanto v. Durnell. Did that shape your preparation or strategy heading into trial?

 

Boehm: Yes, Durnell was central to our planning and strategy, and we were grateful to build on that result. Michelle and I also handled a Roundup trial together last year in which the team knocked out plaintiffs’ failure-to-warn claims at the summary judgment stage, so that was also helpful in preparing for the post-Durnell landscape.

 

When you're standing in front of a jury with people who have cancer and believe your client’s product caused it, how do you balance empathy for those plaintiffs with the advocacy job in front of you?

 

Ramirez: Two things can be true at once: You can and absolutely should have empathy for the three women and their families. Cancer is simply unfair. And each of us have had personal experiences with how horrible cancer is for loved ones. We never lost sight of our sympathy for these women and their families. But we also felt confident based on the overwhelming scientific evidence that Roundup did not cause their cancers.

 

Paul and I were very up front with the jury about our sympathy during opening and closing. And we were up front that we were not asking the jury to side with a company over people, or to disregard their empathy. But we were asking them to follow their duty and the science. What we said was genuine and I think the jury knew that.

 

One thing I noticed reading the openings and closings is that you repeatedly tried to pull the jury back to the same question: What does the science show about causation? Was that the organizing principle of your defense from the beginning?

 

Boehm: You’re right. We felt extremely confident in the strength of the science. We wanted to put the worldwide scientific consensus about Roundup’s safety at the center of the case, and it’s gratifying that’s where the jury kept its focus.

 

We were also fortunate to have world-class experts in epidemiology, chemistry, toxicology and cancer biology who spoke with clarity and conviction.

 

The trial lasted nearly six weeks, but the jury reached a unanimous defense verdict after a relatively short deliberation. Did that surprise you?

 

Ramirez: This was a heavy science case. We were helped tremendously by four incredibly credentialed experts including a chemist, an epidemiologist, a hematologist and a cancer researcher, as well as a regulatory toxicologist from the company. The jury was incredibly diligent for the entire trial; we saw jurors go through multiple notebooks. The speed of this unanimous verdict is a reminder that juries can and will decide cases on the evidence and not on sympathy or prejudice.

 

Plaintiffs' lawyers have argued that after the Durnell decision that other theories remain viable even if failure-to-warn claims do not. How significant do you think this verdict is in that larger Roundup landscape?

 

Boehm: We expect the verdict—which came quickly and unanimously after a long trial—will be significant to the larger litigation. It sends a message that jurors, when given a fair look at the scientific evidence, will get the answer right.  

 

What can other mass-tort defendants take from the way you tried this case?

 

Morgan Branch: I would like to think our work reflects consistency, dogged preparation and attention to the smallest details. We worked to reinforce our core themes at every opportunity—from opening statements through witness examinations and closing arguments—so that the jury heard a consistent, cohesive story. That required not just making complex science accessible, but anticipating issues, refining our presentations, and making sure each part of the case worked together.

 

I think this trial reinforces that there is no substitute for preparation, consistency and credibility, and that the strongest defense is one that earns the jury’s trust at every stage of the case.

 

What will you remember most about this matter?

 

Boehm: The thing I will remember most about this trial is bursting with pride watching our team in action, both in and out of the courtroom. That includes the client, who could not have been more positive, appreciative, and supportive.    

 

Ramirez: Teamwork. I will always remember how quickly all of the firms merged into one trial team, with the goal of trying the best possible case we could. It was seamless, and the positive energy was contagious. That is a huge credit to our client. We are so grateful for their leadership and courage to take this case to verdict.

 

Branch: It’s really the personal moments and relationships built throughout trial that I won’t forget, particularly with the incredible team we had. And being at the table with talent like Paul and Michelle is unmatched.

 

What I'm Reading:

 

Ronald Castille, Former Chief Justice of Pennsylvania and Phila. DA, Dies at 82

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Chief Justice Debra Todd remembered Castille for his legacy of a "commitment to service, duty and the pursuit of justice."

 

Serious Slowdown? What Democrats' Senate Takeover Means for Trump Judicial Picks

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse said he anticipates a "hard reset" on the nominations process when he takes over as Senate Judiciary Committee chair next year.

 

Gov. Newsom Names Trump-Ousted Federal Prosecutor to Sacramento Judgeship

Former Eastern District of California prosecutor Michele Beckwith was one of 23 trial court judges appointed by the governor on Wednesday.

 

'People Wanted Change': Blue Wave Reshapes Texas Courts

The Texas Secretary of State official election results show Democrats won 10 statewide judicial races on Tuesday's ballot: four seats on the Texas Supreme Court, three on the Court of Criminal Appeals and all three on the new 15th Court of Appeals, which hears appeals from the state's business courts.

 

Orrick Adds Fenwick IP Partner in New York

Mark Jansen joins Orrick after 15 years with Fenwick & West.

 

In Case You Missed It:

Courtroom Scenes from Albertsons v. Kroger: A Shelved Merger, Regulatory Strategy and The Pitfalls of Hell or High Water Provisions

At trial before Vice Chancellor Lori Will, each side says the other breached its contractual duties, causing the grocery chain merger to fail.

Connect With Law.com

Terms of Use |  Privacy Policy
© Copyright 2026 ALM Global, LLC trading as Centellic
CENTELLIC
LAW.COM
220 E 42nd St | New York, NY 10017 | 1-877-256-2472